Since the 1930s, smoking cigarettes has proven detrimental to human health and causes lung cancer in addition to heart diseases; tobacco companies reacted by creating the heated tobacco system IQOS, which produces less harmful chemicals according to their advertisements. Do the benefits of IQOS as an alternative e-cigarette outweigh its chemical contaminant output relative to standard cigarette use? Richard needs to examine the chemical makeup, emissions from tobacco use, and the consequences it has on others, along with future health implications of heated tobacco products.
Composition and Mechanism of Action
The heating mechanism of IQOS replaces the burning process which traditional cigarettes use. The system consists of three essential elements: holder, charger and tobacco sticks that come in HEETS or TEREA form. IQOS heats tobacco to a lower temperature of about 350°C, unlike the 600–900°C of conventional cigarettes. The heating method exists to extract nicotine and flavor elements from the tobacco without producing smoke or ash.
The fundamental change occurs with the tobacco material. The tobacco manufacturing process produces shredded tobacco leaves which evolve into processed tobacco sheets containing nicotine, glycerin and additional ingredients for IQOS heatsticks. The product delivers controlled vapor and consistent smoking experience because of this design. In recent years, heatsticks in the USA have been gaining popularity as a possible alternative, with brands like AmericaStick emerging in the market, offering different flavors and nicotine strengths.
The heating blade present inside the IQOS holder functions to puncture heatsticks before gradually warming the tobacco contents. The nicotine delivery method through real tobacco in IQOS matches traditional smoking while e-cigarettes produce vapor from liquid nicotine.
Chemical Emissions and Health Risks
The biggest selling point of IQOS is that it claims to reduce harmful chemical exposure. Over 7,000 chemicals come out of traditional cigarettes, like tar, carbon monoxide, and benzene, which are many of the known carcinogens. Toxic compounds produced in the combustion process increase the risk of lung disease, heart disease, and cancer.
On the other hand, Philip Morris International (PMI), which manufactures IQOS, has conducted some studies showing that heated tobacco produces 90–95 percent fewer harmful chemicals than smoking. However, research that is independent of Philip Morris International shows that IQOS does reduce some of the toxins but does not completely eliminate them. Notably, formaldehyde, acetaldehyde, and acrolein—all toxic to human health—are still present in heated tobacco emissions, though in lower concentrations.
IQOS may reduce chemical exposure but is not risk free.
Secondhand Smoke and Air Quality
Traditional cigarettes are known to contain about 70 known carcinogens in secondhand smoke. The smoke remains in the air and settles on furniture and clothes, becoming thirdhand smoke contamination, and this particularly affects kids and non-smokers.
On the contrary, IQOS generates a smoke-free aerosol, which is often marketed as ‘smoke.’ However, according to research, this aerosol does not contain as many harmful compounds, but it is not entirely harmless. A Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health study reported that IQOs continue to emit nicotine and volatile organic compounds (VOCs) as well as fine particulate matter (PM2.5) — all of which have been shown to have negative impact on indoor air quality.
The second factor to consider is how the aerosol behaves in enclosed spaces. IQOS vapor dissipates quickly, unlike the wide spread of cigarette smoke. But IQOS emissions can still provide nicotine to non-smokers, making it a risk for passive exposure.
The Experience: Taste, Smell, and Ritual
The nicotine itself is not as important to many smokers as the ritual of lighting a cigarette. The smoking experience is completed in the sense that there is the taste, throat hit, hand-to-mouth action, and alternatives like IQOS are either appealing or unsatisfying.
There are a lot of smokers who get satisfaction from traditional cigarettes because they deliver a strong tobacco flavor with a burning sensation in the throat. That is, IQOS offers a milder, smoother draw since the tobacco is heated, not burned. Many users think the taste is a dry, toasted tobacco flavor, while others find it a light,bour line cigarette.
Smell is another key difference. Clothes, hair and furniture become covered with cigarette smoke that leaves a lingering odor. As IQOS produces an aerosol with a weaker and less lingering smell it is more discreet. This can be a huge advantage to users who don’t appreciate the strong aftertaste of cigarettes.
It has a slight variation in the ritual aspect too. IQOS is designed to mimic hand to mouth movement of smoking, however, it does not have the natural burn down process of a cigarette. In other words, users need to manually charge and replace heatsticks, which some find inconvenient.
Public Perception and Social Acceptance
In recent decades, society has changed drastically in its view of smoking. Ban in restaurants, offices, and even some outdoor spaces have made traditional cigarettes heavily stigmatized. Social pressure to quit or switch to alternatives can be made on smokers.
For some, IQOS is seen as more socially acceptable. It produces no strong odor or visible smoke, and many users prefer it because it is less likely to draw attention when being used in public. Nevertheless, it is not accepted by everybody—some still regard it as smoking and do not like it in places shared with others.
There is also a role to play in cultural differences. In Japan, South Korea, and across the continent, IQOS has been wildly adopted, and heated tobacco sales have even overtaken traditional cigarettes. On the contrary, in the U.S. and Europe, the reaction has been mixed, as many still favor e-cigarettes or nicotine pouches.
Impact on Smoking Cessation
Can IQOS help smokers quit? The answer is complicated. IQOS does not intend to eliminate nicotine dependence, unlike nicotine patches or gum. Instead, it is a potentially lower-risk alternative to conventional smoking.
IQOS is also used by some smokers as a step-down method, smoking less until they quit completely. However, the studies show that many users end up dual using — switching between cigarettes and IQOS rather than switching over. It is just as addictive as cigarettes, as the nicotine content still remains high.
While switching to heated tobacco is still considered more effective for those who are genuinely seeking to quit, nicotine replacement therapy (NRT) or behavioral support programs are still considered more effective.
Key takeaways from the comparison
Are IQOS really an alternative to smoking that is cleaner? The black-and-white answer doesn’t exist. IQOS is less harmful than traditional cigarettes because it reduces exposure of harmful chemicals, it does not produce ash, and it does not create as much odor. But it is not risk free – it continues to release toxic substances and the long term health effect remain unknown.
For some smokers, IQOS is a much less harmful option, but for others, it turns into a case of dual use, lit up both cigarettes and IQOS. Officials are still nervous; heated tobacco products are still seen as tobacco products, not cessation aids.
IQOS has benefits from a cost and environmental perspective but also creates new problems in terms of e-waste and battery disposal. However, if your goal is to reduce harm, there is only one truly cleaner option, complete smoking cessation.
Stay in touch to get more updates & alerts on TubeGalore! Thank you
